7 users responded in this post

Get automatic updates to the comments on this post comment rss or trackback url
mygif
Jeff said in July 25th, 2008 at 11:48 pm

Is there any way season a cast iron dutch oven so that it become non-reactive, or is it just best to use enameled cast iron for braising in wine, etc.?

mygif
Jacob said in July 26th, 2008 at 6:26 pm

Jeff,

Some people say that if cast iron is seasoned well enough it will become less reactive. However, none of my research has really led me to believe this.

In the case of braising with red wine or any other median that has a high amount of acid, I would invest in a nice, heavy bottom Anodized Aluminum roasting pan; it will also double up grate as a braising pan.

Save your dutch oven for things like stews and casseroles. An enameled cast iron dutch oven will also do the trick, but the enameled coating is only a little less fragile then the Teflon on a non-stick pan.

mygif
Old Fat Sailor said in July 27th, 2008 at 3:28 am

Beg to differ on that one Jacob. I regularly braise, stew and sauce with my cast iron. However,if you have not inherited great-granny’s pans, it involves quite a bit of work to replicate the carbon that was built up over time by cleaning by basically wiping out the used pan-some times with newsprint!- then setting it back on the hot wood or coal stove. To replicate this one first seasons the pan as described, then oil it, dust the pan with flour, bake till it carbonizes and then do it again and again….. you get the idea. Clean only, and I mean only or you have to star over, with a brief soak on boiling water, wipe out the loose stuff, oil and back to the heat until another layer of carbon forms, cool, rinse out the loose stuff, warm and oil. See simple, ain’t it.

mygif
Jacob said in July 27th, 2008 at 5:16 am

OFS,

Wow, what a simple method for seasoning your cast iron ;-). Braising with cast iron is fine, and unless you’re braising with straight red wine or straight tomato sauce, you’re really never going to have a problem. It’s only the high acid liquids that you really have to concern yourself with.

Even though a well seasoned cast iron pan can multi-task like a mother, I still think that every kitchen should have a nice roasting pan that doubles up as a braising pan as well. Just a personal prefference.

But after 5 generations of seasoning a cast iron pan, you’d probably have to braise with battery acid to ruin your seasoning. My only issue is that high acid foods for an extended period of time in a cast iron pan could release some of the carbon from the seasoning, affecting the overall flavor of your braised dish.

But then again I would hate to argue with you or your grandma about how you choose to use your cast iron heirlooms. It sounds like they’re working out for you just fine.

mygif
lisa 8200 said in July 27th, 2008 at 9:06 pm

a question a little off subject… i would like to replace my home use,pots and pans…. what would be the best for an electric flat top stove???? the only time i get to cook with gas is in my rv, so im going to keep the cast iron for that and will use your technique.. Love the podcast, keep up the great work!!

mygif
Old Fat Sailor said in July 28th, 2008 at 4:36 pm

Yeah, we have an electric flat( no gas service) top and it ain’t the best for cast iron, esp old warped cast iron. I bought a Coleman single gas burner for some tasks that the electric just can’t handle and as an outside canning station. The best I have found for my electric, so far, has been a Peking style carbon steel wok ( Flat bottom-long handle) and some old stock Revere Ware (not the new thin crap) Heat distribution is not a problem on a flat top but pulling heat is and the relativly thin ( as compared to a heavy bottom pan) of the old Revere Ware and carbon steel come in handy, now if I could only find some carbon steel saucepans….YMMV

mygif
Jacob said in August 2nd, 2008 at 6:52 am

@ Lisa

Not knowing what exactly you want or are willing to spend it’s hard to answer this question completely. From my own personal experience though, I have really enjoyed my All Clad cookware and also various roasting pans and such made by Calphalon. Although they are a little pricey, they are durable and are of “heavy” construction giving them good heat retention which is important when doing any type of cooking, but especially on an electric stove. If treated properly, these pans will last you a really long time.

Leave A Reply

 Username (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (*optional)

Please Note: Comment moderation maybe active so there is no need to resubmit your comments